Comments

Fake cycling news, real money: How content farms are hijacking cycling media

Fake cycling news, real money: How content farms are hijacking cycling media

Inside the automated ad-tech machine flooding Facebook with AI-generated cycling misinformation.

Demi Vollering is pregnant, and being cheated on by her partner. Jonas Vingegaard has no time for LGBTQ+ recognition. Mathieu van der Poel has adopted an orphan. Tadej Pogačar is in a feud with Greta Thunberg, telling her to “sit down, Barbie”, live on television.

None of that is true – but if these headlines sound familiar, it might be because you’ve come across them on Facebook, where a coordinated network of ‘news’ pages has been spreading misinformation about professional cycling and its practitioners. 

When one such story popped up in my feed the other day, I was mostly confused and annoyed – but then, I became curious about why this was happening, and who was behind it. What is the motivation behind putting rubbish like this out into the world? Who benefits? And what is the process? 

Fake news makes Tadej cross.

So, I started looking into it all, half-expecting to find some shit-stirring troll hard at work. But what looked like spam or slop turned out to be something much stranger: a sprawling infrastructure churning out hundreds of articles a day across multiple languages and multiple subjects beyond cycling, feeding traffic into two obscure websites. 

The stories might be fake, but the business behind them is real.  

Chapter 1: The pages

We should probably start with the Facebook pages. The first example I came across was a post from a page called Cycling Squad (10,000 followers), but my engagement with that post meant that others soon followed. In total, by following trails of breadcrumbs around Facebook and Google, I’ve now identified 20 such Facebook ‘news pages’ publishing in five languages (English, Dutch/Flemish, French, Spanish, and Italian), with a combined follower count approaching 200,000. 

Cycling page titleFollowers (thousands)Primary language
Cycling Squad10kEnglish
Ciclismo Elite Pro10kSpanish
World Cycle Pulse11kFrench
Cycling Pulse16kEnglish
Cycle Pulse12kEnglish
Sprint Cycle6.2kItalian
Cycling Weekly14kFrench
Cycling Central6.4kDutch
Cycling Pro15kFrench
Dutch Cycling Legends5.6kItalian, weirdly
Race Cycling7.3kFrench
Cycling Empire4.8kDutch
Revved Riders6.5kDutch
Cycling Race Insider5.7kDutch
World Cycling Races6.5kFrench
Rycling Velocity (not a typo)7.9kFrench
Cycling Velocity Hub4.4kDutch
The Cycling Scoop17kFrench
Cycling Signal5.3kDutch
Two Wheels Tribe23k French
Fake cycling news on Facebook: Language and followers

Each of the pages bears some obvious similarities. Firstly, they all have an AI-generated profile picture and header banner – not my jam, personally, but this is the world we live in. As if to bolster their legitimacy, many list addresses in the United States (usually in California, but sometimes Nevada and in one case, Maine). Some also have US phone numbers listed. 

At this point, it’s important you don’t get too excited – as I did, plotting them on a map of the US, looking for a pentagram or something. But there is something they have in common: None of them are in fact home to a Facebook news site, because all of the addresses are hotels (some two-star, some three-star), seemingly plucked at random like the phone numbers. 

Not real locations for any of the HQs of these pages, but looks like a nice roadtrip.

The posts that each profile publishes are, likewise, similar, and in most cases feel calculated to fuel engagement with tabloid-esque language and clickbait content. But they feel familiar enough: race photos of faces you recognise with emotional headlines, and a steady stream of updates calibrated to blend into the feeds of cycling fans. 

Did we do a good job with this story?